Victor Davis Hansen has another timely column today. This one is on dropping out of the popular culture. Some of this is age, of course, but one comment really struck me.
Dr. Hanson, you are not alone in your withdrawal from the post-modern.
I do not own a television, no longer read any print journalism, and the radio antenna on my car was snapped off three years ago by vandals and I haven’t bothered to replace it. The only reason I am even vaguely familiar with the current crop of celebrities comes from standing in supermarket checkout lines and glancing at tabloid magazine covers. In the recent Rush Limbaugh-NFL dustup, I was shocked to learn that the Rams aren’t in Los Angeles anymore. The only movie theatre complex in my community went under this summer, and I didn’t know it for months.
I watch old studio system-era movies on DVDs. I plug my iPod to my car stereo as I drive and listen to music no longer welcomed on a radio station’s playlist. I’m reading a lot more these days: histories, novels and poetry.
What makes this all slightly sad, slightly humorous is that I write for the entertainment industry (thankfully not the Hollywood portion of it). Only the fact that the verities of life are eternal even in fiction and that online social networking (Facebook, Twiter, etc al.) allows me direct contact with my actual audience affords me the ability to still function in near-isolation.
I feel like Edward Grey sometimes. The lights seem to be going out all over Western culture, and I wonder if they will be lit again in my lifetime. The boomers’ lifelong goal of completely obliterating their parents’ world is nearing completion.
It may be that people like you and I are doing the right thing by withdrawing. We are the monks cloistering ourselves in our monasteries with our Latin texts ahead of the coming darkness preserving the old knowledge for the better days that will surely come. And unlike those medieval monks, we have the world’s libraries at our fingertips and the samizdat of the web to connect us in our isolation.
Tho’ much is taken, much abides; and though
We are not now that strength which in old days
Moved earth and heaven; that which we are, we are;
One equal temper of heroic hearts,
Made weak by time and fate, but strong in will
To strive, to seek, to find, and not to yield.
Wow ! I feel almost exactly that way.
Last night, I watched Red Dawn, the new super duper edition. I had always been annoyed at the ending of that movie. After the brothers, Patrick Swayze and Charlie Sheen, had been killed, the narrator’s voice came on and said “The war ended, as wars always do.” I thought that was a very weak and pusillanimous ending for a war movie. In the Collector’s Edition I watched last night, the ending is different ! The weak comment is gone. I suspect some studio wuss added it after the film was finished. Now it’s gone. Enjoy.
I posted a comment on Hansen’s blog agreeing with him but I note it has been deleted in moderation. He did not seem very friendly on the National Review cruise last year, the least friendly of the speakers, and I suspect he is not a very friendly guy. At one point, I was thinking of signing up for a cruise he does but maybe not. It was pretty expensive, anyway. I still agree with his post but that doesn’t seem to be enough. Anyway, the quote above is from a commenter, not the professor.
A few of his real life stories of his central valley growing up gave a hint of some aloofness. Not a bad thing for an observer and critic of modern life, in my estimation. But it would seem an undesirable trait in a cruise speaker where mingling with great minds is a selling point.
Had a good laugh at my tea bag faux pas a few posts down.
I read the same column by Hansen. I think you’re even righter, the lights are going out in Western culture. I read a blog on economics by Fernandez that led me to the same conclusion.
‘Or else Richard Fernandez who wrote the article “Buy One Take Ten” is right, our governments are clinically insane. But I think there may be another explanation. I think our government will spend money as long as they can get away with it. Sooner or later the proverbial ‘shit’ will hit the fan, and something will happen that is intolerable to somebody, or lots of somebodies.
Of course, with the Maoists the US has in office, 40 to 70 million of us could starve to death, and they’d still be looking up to Chairman Obama as their favorite political philosopher.
Is this the end of the noble experiment of Western Culture? The one that believes in a human centered world, in rational explanations, and love thy neighbor. I can’t believe that Western Culture will lose, because I believe that Western philosophy is intrinsically correct about human nature, God, and the fun of living. But we could be in for a Dark Ages, I guess. Hopefully it won’t last a thousand years, like the last one.’